Saturday, September 6, 2014

A Ceasefire in Doubt

A man rides past a Ukrainian BTR-3 or BTR-4 in Mariupol.
Photo: Reuters/Vasily Fedosenko
The Ukrainian government and Pro-Russian separatists both accuse each other of breaking a new ceasefire. Despite ambiguous announcements over the last few days, a ceasefire the Ukrainian government and pro-Russian separatists agreed to in Minsk yesterday has mostly held. A lasting peace deal was hoped to be just around the corner – but that won’t happen if the ceasefire collapses. So far, at least 2,600 people have been killed in the fighting, not including the 298 passengers and crew of Malaysia Airlines flight MH17. Over a million people have been displaced.

A prisoner exchange was planned for later today.

The Situation on the Ground

The Ukrainian military sabotaged the airstrip of Luhansk Airpot before separatist forces – including Russian troops, according to Ukrainian representatives – recaptured it. Dontesk Airport was still contested when the ceasefire took effect; it’s unclear who controls it. Both airports were focal points of the recent fighting. The separatists themselves probably do not have the resources to repair the airstrip in Luhansk – and without any functioning aircraft of their own, they have little reason to.

Mariupol remains in Ukrainian hands, despite a direct armored attack on it in the hours before the ceasefire. The attack was supported by heavy artillery fire, including multiple rocket launchers. Shortly before the attack, the Russian ambassador to the OSCE predicted that pro-Russian separatists would “liberate” the city, noting that the civilian population of the region “are ethnic Russians, though they have Ukrainian passports.”

It’s unlikely that the offensive towards Mariupol would have actually succeeded in creating a land route to Crimea. The offensive was probably either an attempt to give the separatists access to the sea and expand the territory under their control, or a feint to draw Ukrainian forces away from Donetsk and Luhansk.

The Ukrainian military was on the verge of recapturing both Donetsk and Luhansk when what appears to be an overt intervention by the Russian military swept into the country. Evidence of this is now overwhelming. Ukraine has captured Russian soldiers. Others have been killed. One Russian unit has even been decorated for some unknown reason. Photographs – including satellite photographs – abound.

A T-72B3 claimed to have been captured by Ukrainian forces
near Ilovaisk on August 28.

A Note on Tanks

Ukrainian representatives describe “Russian tank battalions” as leading the recent separatist offensives. The existence of concentrated armored units (a full-strength Russian armored battalion has 30 tanks) is unprecedented in the conflict.

In the first few months of the fighting, tanks in separatist hands were few and far between, generally being seen at most three at a time. The separatists even used World War 2-era tanks from war monuments to supplement their sparse arsenal. In recent months the number of tanks being used by the separatists has swelled to hundreds – far more than have been captured from the Ukrainian military. Either the tanks are from Russia, or the separatists suddenly developed the capability to produce them to modern Russian standards extremely rapidly.

Observers have identified the T-72B3 in photos of tanks recently captured by the Ukrainian military. The Russian military began acquiring T-72B3s, one of the newest Russian models of T-72, last year. The T-72 is a Soviet-designed tank that is still in widespread use. One photographs shows a T-72B3 with the white stripes the Ukrainian military has used to indicate not being separatist – suggesting a possible attempted “ruse of war” to sneak past Ukrainian positions. Variants of the T-72B3 were also used in a recent “tank biathlon”.

No comments:

Post a Comment